Barnes & Noble vs. Borders
I will never enter another Barnes & Noble again.
Today I went to get a book from Barnes & Noble. After wandering for ten minutes looking for the right section, I couldn’t find the book anywhere. You see, it’s not that the shelves are disorganized; they are organized. It’s just that they are organized completely illogically. Obviously, the staff at Barnes & Noble are possibly illiterate and probably have never heard of library science. So, when I went to the information desk to ask the disgruntled employee to search for the book for me, she was perfectly unhappy to do so. I asked her to search for the title Flesh and Spirit. None of the books listed under that title or under any of the other searches that we tried matched that description. Not wanting to tax the skills of this obviously well-trained customer service representative any further, I exercised my prerogative as a consumer in a capitalist nation and drove one hundred yards down the street.
There I entered Borders Books and Music. I passed through the lobby, which unlike Barnes and Noble was not cluttered with cheap picture books for illiterate people, and entered a large room with books stacked neatly on well-arranged shelves. A quick perusal of some of the shelves that I passed revealed several classic titles in attractive editions that I was interested in and not lopsided piles of Arts and Crafts for Dummies and such like. I went to one of several computer kiosks and this time I typed in the title Flesh and Spirit myself. (At least this time I could be sure that it was spelled correctly.) Lo and behold! the first title on the list was Spirit and Flesh. I had the title backwards, but somehow the Borders computer was smart enough to know exactly what I was looking for anyway. The computer gave me all the relevant bibliographical and price information and even gave me an exact location for the book (section 2a, shelf F1). Two minutes later I had the book in hand and could have been out the door minutes later. However, I stayed for another ten or fifteen minutes just looking at the books in the religion section. Unlike Barnes & Noble, whose religion section consisted primarily of The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Zen Buddhism, there were actually books that a conservative, evangelical fundamentalist could read—even own—with profit. My perusing completed, a happy, smiling, competent (and cute) employee helped me pay for the book while chatting pleasantly. Borders even gave me thirty percent off the next book that I buy there. Since they gave me an enjoyable and profitable book-buying experience, I’m sure I’ll be back to use that coupon. Barnes & Noble ain’t got nothin’ on Borders.
I will never enter another Barnes & Noble again.
Disclaimer: This post is the first in the new category entitled “My Two Cents.” Posts like this one will be so labeled, not so that you can seek them out but so that you can seek to avoid them. I will try to keep the number of these posts to a minimum.
Posted 22 Jun. 2005 at 11:31 pm | Permalink
Hey Lincoln, that post was hilarious.
I also have noticed a lack of helpfulness among B&N employees. I do not believe that this lack of cooperation is due to their illiteracy, however. I believe that they are actually quite smart (crafty might be a better word). They realize that they get paid the same amount of money whether they help you or not. So all they do is try to be as unhelpful as possible until you disappear.
Of course, I always thought Borders was better just because they have a larger comic book selection ;-).
Posted 2 Jul. 2005 at 1:38 pm | Permalink
Hey Link! How about we open a Border’s in G’ville? You do the books, I’ll see about coffee, and we can have alternating philosophy/religion/fundamentalism discusions on friday and saturday nights!
Of course, your dad would have to front the money…. :D
Posted 7 Jul. 2005 at 10:13 am | Permalink
I too shall boycot B&N on your behalf, for their illogical order of books, for when I enter this establishment in my home town
I find the same chaos and cocophany of illiterate mess greeting me at the from door and inept lugubrious sales limnings with the same
ready reckoners that can not seem to find what I am looking for, although I must say, ordering on line has ne’er brought me any conundrom
Thanks for the descry.
Posted 9 Apr. 2006 at 8:44 am | Permalink
There is a Borders in Greenville. It’s in Haywood Mall, and even though it’s small and, well, in a mall, B&N’s got nothing on my Borders. They have books there that are actually appealing.
Posted 9 Apr. 2006 at 8:55 pm | Permalink
You know, I’ve noticed the same thing at the Barnes & Noble in Mishawaka. I went one day to look for an origami book and, after hunting for almost an hour, found it wedged between the knitting books and the meditating on colors books. Oh, and Jubilant Sykes was catagorized under “Vocal Jazz” (are you kidding me?) and shelved under “New Age” (not even close). Grrr. I’ll try Borders next time.
Posted 13 Apr. 2006 at 7:04 pm | Permalink
I just recently signed up for a Borders reward card. It has been well worth it. Just about every week I get on line coupons for 25% off one book. They only last for a week, but if I buy something that week I save. They are supposedly adding up my points to give me some kind of a discount at Christmas time. Sometimes you get coupons for 10% off your total purchase. Besides their books they have great little trinkets for gifts and a much better food selection, oh, and tea, too. I am not a purest like Lincoln. Although I am a great book-lover, I can also be distracted by all the other things. They also have free gift- wrapping. Maybe they will offer me extra points for this free advertising.
Lincoln, if you go there give them our home phone number so I can get credit. I might use it to get you a present.
Posted 3 Aug. 2006 at 1:50 pm | Permalink
I’ve never been to a Barnes and Noble in the USA, so I can’t judge you, but I have been to the two (and only) Barnes and Noble in Grenada and found it a very enjoyable place to shop. Maybe it’s just Americans or something, I don’t know. I’m prejudiced for Grenada anyway, so always root for them.
Posted 24 Sep. 2006 at 7:40 pm | Permalink
I’m a B&N Employee, and to be honest one of the main reason I had chosen to work there over Borders was because as a customer, I always had a more pleasant shopping experience there. Maybe the one the original poster went to had a fairly incompetent bookseller, but in my experience the booksellers had almost always been able to locate and/or order the title for me. In the event that they didn’t have it, they were always able to order a title quicker than Borders (try two days as opposed to two weeks). As an employee, I think B&N has a very pleasant working environment, complete with full training and benefits.